
Interwar Peak (1918–1945) · Skillet
Used price$90–$220see eBay picks
Favorite cookware comes from a short window, which makes it scarcer than Griswold or Wagner. Favorite Stove & Range Co. of Piqua, Ohio, was mainly a stove maker. It expanded its cast iron cookware around 1916 and sold the cookware tooling in 1935 when the company wound down. The No. 8 is about 10½ inches across. You'll see several marks on these pans. There's the Favorite Piqua Ware block logo, the smiley logo (a curved line under the name), the early "Best to Cook In" mark, and dual-marked pans carrying the Miami diamond, Favorite's budget line. Size numbers often carry a letter, as in 8A. Smiley-logo pans are the most common and the cheapest, while "Best to Cook In" and dual-logo pans ask more. Collectors go for the early marks, but a smiley pan that sits flat cooks just as well.
Warp is common, and listings that admit a pan isn't flat turn up often. Hairline cracks, repaired cracks and pitting are the other faults to look for.
Good to know. Most genuine No. 8s ask about $120–250 delivered. Smiley-logo pans start around $95–160, and the one 8A listed, a restored pan, asks about $199.
How to identify a real Favorite Stove
FAVORITE PIQUA WARE in an arc or block layout, often with a curved smiley line underneath, plus a size number that may carry a letter (8A). Some pans add BEST TO COOK IN, and some carry the MIAMI diamond. Puritan-marked pieces were made for Sears. The bare word Favorite without Piqua doesn't prove this maker.
Buying guide
From Oct 19, 2026 listings
On a Favorite No. 8, the mark sets the price. Smiley-logo pans are the cheap way in at around $90–140 delivered, while "Best to Cook In" and Miami dual-logo pans run to the top of the $90–220 band and past it. The word Favorite alone proves nothing, so read Piqua Ware in the bottom photo. To cook, we'd take the restored smiley pan listed as flat.

Listed as flat, at about $89 delivered. The Miami diamond is Favorite's budget-line mark, so ask for a bottom photo that shows Piqua Ware too.
Rare Antique Favorite Piqua Ware 8 Miami Diamond Logo Cast Iron Skillet Flat

Smiley logo, restored and listed as flat, inside the band at $140. That covers everything a cooking pan needs.
Favorite Piqua Ware Smiley Logo #8 Cast Iron Skillet. Restored. Sits Flat

A first-timer can cook on this one without stripping it. Shipping isn't stated, so ask what it adds before you buy.
Favorite Piqua Ware Smiley Logo #8 Cast Iron Skillet. Restored. Sits Flat

Already restored, so oil and heat are all that stand between it and the stove.
Favorite Piqua Ware Smiley Logo #8 Cast Iron Skillet. Restored. Sits Flat

Marked "The Best to Cook In", the early mark collectors pay up for, and this listing isn't one of the copied titles. Ask whether it sits flat.
Favorite Piqua Ware Cast Iron Skillet Frying Pan #8 Marked “The Best to Cook In”

Cracked and repaired, at about $50. A repair can open again under heat, so treat it as a wall pan.
The Favorite Piqua Ware #8 Cast Iron Skillet *Cracked and Repaired*
Delivered prices include shipping as eBay quoted it to a US address on Oct 19, 2026. Many sellers charge by distance, so your total may differ. eBay shows yours before you pay.
Market snapshot
8 of 182 listed
Checked . Some may have sold.
Delivered prices include shipping as eBay quoted it to a US address on Oct 19, 2026. Many sellers charge by distance, so your total may differ. eBay shows yours before you pay.
Used$88.74est. delivered
$75.99 + $12.75 shipping
Buy It Now$75.99
Good buy
Miami diamond mark, listed as flat.
Seller: gumboyayagarlic
99.8% positive
Restored$140.00+ shipping
$140.00 · shipping not stated
Buy It Now$140.00
Good buy
Smiley logo, restored, and sits flat per the title.
Seller: fleamarketal
100% positive
Used$210.90est. delivered
$190.00 + $20.90 shipping
Buy It Now$190.00
This seller takes offers, and many sellers accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
Good buy
"The Best to Cook In" mark. Ask about flatness.
Seller: cahan_2452
100% positive
For parts$49.99delivered
$49.99 · free shipping
Buy It Now$49.99
Project piece
Cracked and repaired per the title. Keep it off the stove.
Seller: oldstationironworks
100% positive
Used$92.98est. delivered
$69.99 + $22.99 shipping
Buy It Now$69.99
This seller takes offers, and many sellers accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
Our take
Smiley logo with Best Offer open. Nearly $23 of the total is shipping.
Seller: bigd923
100% positive
Restored$218.00est. delivered
$200.00 + $18.00 shipping
Buy It Now$200.00
This seller takes offers, and many sellers accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
Our take
Arc logo with a heat ring, restored and flat per the title.
Seller: taylorflyinirons
100% positive
Used$279.48est. delivered
$264.69 + $14.79 shipping
Buy It Now$264.69
Check the seller
Three sellers use this same title. Compare photos and seller history first.
Seller: mapleleaves4me8jx0
99.4% positive
Used$618.00est. delivered
$599.00 + $19.00 shipping
Buy It Now$599.00
This seller takes offers, and many sellers accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
Priced high
A dual-logo pan with a wood handle at over twice the band.
Seller: mcna9695
100% positive
Prices change daily. The live eBay search shows everything listed now, including anything new since Oct 19, 2026.
See every listing on eBay →What you need to clean, season and look after a piece like this. The links are plain Amazon searches, and we earn nothing from them.
Scrubs off stuck-on food under hot water without stripping the seasoning, and it lasts for years. If you buy one $15 accessory for old cast iron, make it this.
Search on AmazonA popular seasoning oil that bakes into a hard finish, though some people find it flakes. A six-coat re-season takes a Saturday and lasts for years.
Search on AmazonSlips over a hot handle so you can carry the pan from stove to table. Old Griswold and Wagner handles get very hot, and with one of these on you won't need a glove for a short trip.
Search on AmazonPlastic scrapers shaped for corners and curved edges. They lift stuck-on food without scoring the seasoning, so they're safer than a metal spatula on a machined cooking surface.
Search on Amazontypical $70–$150
c. 1916–1935

typical $70–$160
c. 1916–1935

typical $80–$180
c. 1916–1935

typical $90–$220
c. 1920–1940