Interwar Peak (1918–1945) · Muffin Pan
Used price$70–$150see eBay picks
Marked Favorite gem pans are much harder to find than Wagner or Griswold ones, so the mark is what you're paying for. This is an 11-cup muffin (gem) pan from Favorite Stove & Range Co. of Piqua, Ohio, roughly 11 by 7⅝ inches and about 1⅝ inches deep. Eleven cups was a common layout across several makers, Wagner and Griswold among them. The Piqua Ware mark on the back is what identifies a Favorite pan, and an unmarked 11-cup pan can't be attributed from the cup layout alone. Favorite's bread-stick and corn pans also turn up in the same searches, and they're different items. Pay Favorite money only when you can read Piqua Ware in the photo.
A through-crack in any cup takes roughly 40–60% off the value. Frames and handles crack too, and cleaning can soften the mark. Carbon in the cups is only cosmetic.
Good to know. Nothing was listed in the latest snapshot, so the band is a catalog estimate. They come up rarely enough that a saved search is how you catch one.
How to identify a real Favorite Stove
FAVORITE PIQUA WARE in an arc or block layout, often with a curved smiley line underneath, plus a size number that may carry a letter (8A). Some pans add BEST TO COOK IN, and some carry the MIAMI diamond. Puritan-marked pieces were made for Sears. The bare word Favorite without Piqua doesn't prove this maker.
Buying guide
From Sep 25, 2026 listings
Nothing's listed right now, and the last band we saw for an 11-cup Favorite was about $70–150 delivered. These turn up now and then, so set a saved search and wait. When one appears, read Piqua Ware on the back and get a photo held up to the light. A through-crack in any cup takes roughly 40–60% off.
Market snapshot
None listed
Nothing was listed when we checked on .
Prices change daily. The live eBay search shows everything listed now, including anything new since Sep 25, 2026.
See every listing on eBay →What you need to clean, season and look after a piece like this. The links are plain Amazon searches, and we earn nothing from them.
Heat-resistant silicone for greasing the inside of every muffin or cornstick cavity before baking. It outlasts natural bristle and goes in the dishwasher.
Search on AmazonA popular seasoning oil that bakes into a hard finish, though some people find it flakes. A six-coat re-season takes a Saturday and lasts for years.
Search on AmazonRust remover, sandpaper in several grits, seasoning wax and cotton applicators in one set. Use it on pieces that need a full strip and re-season, like rust-pitted finds or heavy carbon buildup.
Search on Amazon
typical $110–$280
c. 1916–1935

typical $90–$250
c. 1916–1935

typical $70–$160
c. 1916–1935

typical $60–$160
Late 1800s–1950s (many variations)