Griswold · Wagner Ware · Early Lodge · Favorite · Vollrath
Old American cast iron was often milled smooth inside, and a pan that’s already cooked for 80 years still has decades left in it. We cover 36 pieces from 5 makers. Each page shows the marks that date it, what to check before you buy and what it should cost, then picks the eBay listings we’d buy.
Where to start
The pans most first-time buyers go looking for, across makers, sizes and the most valuable types.

c. 1920–1940
typical $90–$220typical used price

c. 1939–1957
typical $50–$130typical used price

c. 1922–1959
typical $70–$150typical used price

c. 1940s–1980s
typical $30–$80typical used price

c. 1920–1957
typical $110–$260typical used price

c. 1930s–1950s
typical $30–$75typical used price
Deal finder
Don’t search “cast iron pan.” Search the maker, size, pattern number and logo. That’s how you find the underpriced listings other buyers scroll past.
good → Griswold 8 large logo 704
weak → old cast iron skillet
Tap to build your query
Opens a plain eBay search in a new tab. We earn nothing from it.
Before you buy
eBay has the most listings and the best buyer protection. Etsy runs about 20–30% higher with weaker recourse. Flea markets and estate sales give the most iron per dollar, as long as you know what you're holding.
Combine the maker, size, pattern number and logo. A search for “Griswold 8 large logo 704” turns up the mispriced listings that “cast iron skillet” buries.
Watch for listings with no photo of the bottom, a “100-year-old” pan that looks factory-clean, “Griswold-style” in the title, or a handle hidden in every shot. Ask the seller for a photo of the stamp and of the pan sitting on a flat surface before you buy.
The heavy part
A skillet is heavy, cracks if it’s dropped, and rusts if it travels damp. A great piece can arrive chipped or orange, so sort these out before you pay.
Rule of thumb
A boxed No. 10 skillet weighs about 7–9 lb, so budget $14–22 for ground shipping. Ask to bundle several pieces in one box to split the cost.
The maker's mark, size and pattern number are all on the bottom, and so are most cracks and warps. No clear photo of the underside? Skip the listing.
Good sellers wrap the piece dry in paper and double-box it. A loose skillet in a thin box arrives with chipped rims, and iron wrapped damp shows up orange with surface rust.
Iron is dense, so shipping is a real part of the price. A boxed No. 8 skillet weighs about 6 lb and a Dutch oven 10 lb or more. Buying several pieces in one box is the cheapest way to start a small collection.
Photograph the piece as soon as you unbox it. eBay's protection covers an item that isn't as described, like an undisclosed crack or warp, but only if you open a case quickly with evidence.
Read before you buy
Erie-made Griswold lists for several times what lookalikes, Sidney-made pieces and recasts ask. Four checks tell the real thing apart before you buy.
5 min read
Date a used Wagner pan by its mark, from plain WAGNER to the 1922 stylized logo's heat-ring and smooth-bottom years, and size it against Griswold.
5 min read
Rust, crud and worn seasoning come off. Cracks, warps, deep pitting and fire damage don't. How to read the photos and price each defect into an offer.
5 min read
Most rusty, crusted vintage iron can be stripped and re-seasoned over a weekend with basic materials. The methods, safety rules and costly mistakes.
5 min read
Casual sellers list most vintage cast iron, and they mean well. Seven signs in a listing that you should ask harder questions, or walk away.
5 min read
Collector questions
Start with the logo on the bottom. The large block logo, with GRISWOLD in big upright letters filling much of the cross-and-circle, dates from about 1920 to 1940. The small block logo, a much smaller stamp near the center, runs from about 1939 to 1957, when the Erie foundry closed. Earlier pans carry the slant logo or just ERIE. On a No. 8 skillet the large logo lists for about $100–190 and the small logo about $80–100, so ask for a clear photo of the bottom before you pay large-logo money.