Piece type
Stovetop waffle irons are the trickiest vintage cast iron buy, because you're buying three parts. You need two paddles from the same model, a hinge that closes them flat without play, and the base ring that sits over the stove opening. Most listings show only the closed iron, so ask for photos of both inside faces, the hinge and the base, and ask whether the base is included. Complete with the base, Griswold's American and New American No. 8 irons usually list for about $150–280, and Wagner No. 8 irons for about $110–220. Griswold's heart-shaped Heart & Star irons are a separate, pricier model. Check every part for cracks, make sure the hinge isn't seized with rust, and expect worn or replaced handles. Paddles listed without a base are worth noticeably less.
2 waffle irons from the five makers we cover.