Piece type
Griddles are flat cooking surfaces with a low rim or none, and they're what you want for pancakes, bacon and flatbreads. Round handle griddles such as the Griswold No. 9 (pattern 609) and the Wagner No. 9 (catalog 1109) are the most common, and long two-burner griddles and square pans also turn up. A griddle has almost no sidewall, so warp is the main risk on any of them. Ask for a photo of it lying flat on a counter, and look for a gap under the edge or a center that spins. Long two-burner griddles are more prone to warp than round ones. Then check the low rim for chips and missing chunks, which can't be repaired, and look for hairline cracks running in from the edge.
4 griddles from the five makers we cover.

typical $60–$200
c. 1920–1957

typical $50–$130
c. 1930s–1950s

typical $80–$180
c. 1916–1935
typical $60–$130
Early 1900s–1940s (approx.)