
Interwar Peak (1918–1945) · Griddle
Used price$75–$210see eBay picks
Wagner's square pan is the one to reach for when you're making bacon, sandwiches or square-cut cornbread. It's catalog number 1218, often with a letter such as 1218 B, C or D. It measures about 9½ inches square, has a thumb rest on the handle, and sellers list it as both a square skillet and a griddle. The bottom carries the stylized Wagner Ware Sidney -O- logo. It's less common than Wagner's round skillets and handle griddles. Don't confuse it with Wagner's round No. 9 handle griddle, which is catalog 1109 and a different piece. Square Magnalite griddles show up in the same search, and those are cast aluminum. When one turns up, look for 1218 on the bottom and four clean corners.
Corners take the knocks, so they chip or crack first. Warp, pitting and plating turn up as on any Wagner pan. The search also mixes in Magnalite aluminum griddles and round 1109 griddles listed as square.
Good to know. Few are listed at any time, so save a search and be ready when one appears.
How to identify a real Wagner Ware
The stylized Wagner Ware Sidney -O- logo on the bottom, with a four-digit catalog number (1058 on the No. 8 skillet, 1059 on the No. 9) and a mold letter. Earlier pans show a plain WAGNER or Wagner Ware mark with SIDNEY O. and a size number. Later pieces read Wagner Ware with MADE IN USA. Magnalite pieces are aluminum, not iron.
Buying guide
From Oct 19, 2026 listings
Only one square skillet is listed, in a search full of round 1109 handle griddles. It has the thumb-rest handle of the 1218 and asks $75 before shipping. The $75–210 band rests on just two square pans, the other being the larger 1220 at about $212 delivered. Ask for a bottom photo to confirm 1218 and the Sidney -O- logo, look at all four corners for chips, and ask whether it sits flat.

It's the only 1218-style pan listed, and the thumb-rest handle fits. The title gives no number, so get the bottom photo before you buy.
Wagner Ware Cast Iron Square Skillet/Griddle, Handle w/ Thumb Made in USA
Delivered prices include shipping as eBay quoted it to a US address on Oct 19, 2026. Many sellers charge by distance, so your total may differ. eBay shows yours before you pay.
Market snapshot
2 of 277 listed
Checked . Some may have sold.
Delivered prices include shipping as eBay quoted it to a US address on Oct 19, 2026. Many sellers charge by distance, so your total may differ. eBay shows yours before you pay.
Used$75.00+ shipping
$75.00 · shipping not stated
Buy It Now$75.00
Good buy
Thumb-rest handle of the square 1218. Ask for a bottom photo to confirm the number.
Seller: bluebird3sewing
100% positive
Used$211.95est. delivered
$152.00 + $59.95 shipping
Buy It Now$152.00
Our take
The larger 1220 square skillet, unrestored per the title.
Seller: k1vintage
100% positive
Prices change daily. The live eBay search shows everything listed now, including anything new since Oct 19, 2026.
See every listing on eBay →What you need to clean, season and look after a piece like this. The links are plain Amazon searches, and we earn nothing from them.
Scrubs off stuck-on food under hot water without stripping the seasoning, and it lasts for years. If you buy one $15 accessory for old cast iron, make it this.
Search on AmazonPlastic scrapers shaped for corners and curved edges. They lift stuck-on food without scoring the seasoning, so they're safer than a metal spatula on a machined cooking surface.
Search on AmazonKeeps bacon flat on the griddle so it cooks evenly, and doubles as a panini press. It's also a quick flatness test. If the press won't sit flush, the griddle has warped.
Search on AmazonA popular seasoning oil that bakes into a hard finish, though some people find it flakes. A six-coat re-season takes a Saturday and lasts for years.
Search on Amazon
typical $40–$100
c. 1922–1959

typical $80–$200
c. 1891–1922

typical $50–$120
c. 1922–1959

typical $60–$200
c. 1920–1957