
Pre-WWI Golden Age (1890–1917) · Skillet
Used price$110–$130see eBay picks
Before its fancy stylized logo, Wagner marked its iron with the plain word WAGNER. It ran straight or in an arc, later with SIDNEY O. below, and from about 1914 the pans read "Wagner Ware" in plain lettering. The stylized logo arrived around 1922. These early No. 9 skillets are about 11¼ inches across and usually have a heat ring and a size number, often with a letter (9 A, 9 B). They're scarcer than the stylized-logo 1059, and collectors pay more for clean, unplated examples. Many early Wagner pans were nickel plated, though. Almost everything in a search for this pan is the later stylized-logo No. 9, a different and cheaper skillet, so a clear bottom photo of the early mark comes first.
Plating is the common flaw. Nickel that has worn through or is flaking is a real problem on a cooking surface, and pitting can hide under it. Hairline cracks and warp also turn up.
Good to know. These turn up rarely, and unplated ones more rarely still, so let a saved search do the looking.
How to identify a real Wagner Ware
The stylized Wagner Ware Sidney -O- logo on the bottom, with a four-digit catalog number (1058 on the No. 8 skillet, 1059 on the No. 9) and a mold letter. Earlier pans show a plain WAGNER or Wagner Ware mark with SIDNEY O. and a size number. Later pieces read Wagner Ware with MADE IN USA. Magnalite pieces are aluminum, not iron.
Buying guide
From Oct 20, 2026 listings
Only a handful here are early Wagner No. 9s with the plain WAGNER mark. The rest are later stylized-logo 1059s and No. 6s. Early pans ask $110–130 delivered. The 9D the seller dates to 1897 to 1905 asks $100 plus shipping and is the one a collector would want. Get a clear bottom photo of the mark, and check for flaking nickel plating, which rules out cooking.

$100 before shipping for a 9D with an early mark in the title. Ask for a bottom photo and a shot of it sitting flat.
Early Wagner Sidney - O No. 9D Cast Iron Skillet c. 1897 – 1905

An arc-and-straight logo 9A with an outside heat ring, at about $121 delivered. Ask about plating and whether it sits flat.
Wagner Arc Straight Logo #9A Cast Iron Skillet w/Outside Heat Ring 12” Diameter

If the seller's 1897 to 1905 date holds, it's one of the oldest Wagner pans you can buy. Confirm the mark before you pay for the date.
Early Wagner Sidney - O No. 9D Cast Iron Skillet c. 1897 – 1905
Delivered prices include shipping as eBay quoted it to a US address on Oct 20, 2026. Many sellers charge by distance, so your total may differ. eBay shows yours before you pay.
Market snapshot
7 of 8 listed
Checked . Some may have sold.
Delivered prices include shipping as eBay quoted it to a US address on Oct 20, 2026. Many sellers charge by distance, so your total may differ. eBay shows yours before you pay.
Used$100.00+ shipping
$100.00 · shipping not stated
Buy It Now$100.00
This seller takes offers, and many sellers accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
Good buy
9D, dated 1897 to 1905 by the seller.
Seller: kitchensforgoodshop
99.8% positive
Used$120.54est. delivered
$89.99 + $30.55 shipping
Buy It Now$89.99
Good buy
Arc and straight logo 9A, outside heat ring.
Seller: keystonerelics
100% positive
For parts$82.45est. delivered
$60.00 + $22.45 shipping
Buy It Now$60.00
This seller takes offers, and many sellers accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
Our take
Hairline crack per the title. Not for the stove.
Seller: patrickwjoyce2006
100% positive
Used$105.99est. delivered
$89.99 + $16.00 shipping
Buy It Now$89.99
Our take
Sidney 9 B. The title doesn't say which mark, so check the bottom photo.
Seller: theus-y3g2lpg
99.9% positive
Used$120.19est. delivered
$109.87 + $10.32 shipping
Buy It Now$109.87
This seller takes offers, and many sellers accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
Our take
Arc and straight logo No. 9.
Seller: ace_6137
100% positive
Used$133.17est. delivered
$120.00 + $13.17 shipping
Buy It Now$120.00
This seller takes offers, and many sellers accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
Our take
Arc and straight logo 9 B with a heat ring, dated 1915 to the 1920s.
Seller: cupb06
100% positive
Used$94.33est. delivered
$80.00 + $14.33 shipping
Buy It Now$80.00
This seller takes offers, and many sellers accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
Check the seller
Early Wagner No. 9. Seller feedback is 97.4%.
Seller: classictreasures4us
97.4% positive
Prices change daily. The live eBay search shows everything listed now, including anything new since Oct 20, 2026.
See every listing on eBay →What you need to clean, season and look after a piece like this. The links are plain Amazon searches, and we earn nothing from them.
Scrubs off stuck-on food under hot water without stripping the seasoning, and it lasts for years. If you buy one $15 accessory for old cast iron, make it this.
Search on AmazonA popular seasoning oil that bakes into a hard finish, though some people find it flakes. A six-coat re-season takes a Saturday and lasts for years.
Search on AmazonSlips over a hot handle so you can carry the pan from stove to table. Old Griswold and Wagner handles get very hot, and with one of these on you won't need a glove for a short trip.
Search on AmazonPlastic scrapers shaped for corners and curved edges. They lift stuck-on food without scoring the seasoning, so they're safer than a metal spatula on a machined cooking surface.
Search on Amazon
typical $150–$320
c. 1920s–1940s

typical $50–$130
c. 1930s–1950s

typical $35–$90
c. 1920s–1950s

typical $90–$220
c. 1920–1940