Piece type
Vintage Dutch ovens and round roasters are bought as a set, and the lid decides the value. A matched lid carries the same maker and size as the body and seats in the lid ledge without rocking. On collectible models it bears its own pattern number. Griswold's Tite-Top lids are pattern 2551 on the No. 8, and Wagner's Drip Drop Baster lids are lettered DRIP DROP with patent dates. Ask for photos of both undersides before you buy, and look for cracks around the bail ears and across the bottom, chips in the rim and lid ledge, and pitting inside. A complete Griswold No. 8 Tite-Top with its matched lid typically lists for about $120–220. Wagner, Favorite and vintage Lodge ovens usually ask similar money or less, and bodies without lids ask much less.
5 dutch ovens from the five makers we cover.

typical $110–$260
c. 1920–1957

typical $90–$260
c. 1920s–1959

typical $150–$320
c. 1920s–1940s

typical $60–$150
Mid-1900s (approx.)

typical $110–$280
c. 1916–1935