Piece type
Muffin and gem pans are the most pattern-rich corner of vintage cast iron. Griswold alone made dozens of numbered gem pans, among them the No. 10 popover pan (11 cups) and the No. 11 French roll pan (12 cups, pattern 950), and collectors catalog many casting variations of the same number. Eleven-cup pans were common across makers, so go by the maker's mark instead of the cup count. The key check is a through-crack in any cup. Hold the pan up to the light, because a single cracked cup takes roughly 40–60% off the value. Carbon inside the cups is cosmetic and comes out with a proper strip. Many old gem pans are unmarked and can only be attributed by pattern comparison, so don't pay marked-pan prices for an unmarked one.
3 muffin pans from the five makers we cover.